Sequential or parallel review: how to organize several reviewers
When a document needs the opinion of several people, you can pass it from one reviewer to the next, or send the same file to everyone at once. The first is slower but keeps a single thread of comments; the second is faster but leaves you with several sets of comments to reconcile.
At a glance
| Aspect | Sequential review | Parallel review |
|---|---|---|
| Time | Adds up the time of every reviewer. | About the time of the slowest reviewer. |
| Comments | One file collects everything, and later reviewers see earlier remarks. | Several files, each with its own comments to reconcile. |
| Conflicts | Rare, because each person works on the latest version. | Likely when two reviewers ask for different things. |
| Version control | One current version at any time. | Several copies of the same baseline in circulation. |
Tie every copy to the same starting point
Parallel review works only if everyone starts from the same file, so fix the version first and number its pages, which makes comments easy to place. Page numbers and Bates numbering give each page a reference, and a draft watermark makes it plain that the file is not final. When the copies return, Compare PDFs can show on which pages each one differs from the baseline, and Merge PDF can join returned files into one for the author. Every tool creates a new file, so the version you sent stays as it was. Practical tip: in a sequential review each reviewer receives the previous reviewer's version, so a single file travels and conflicts are rare, but the process is slow. In a parallel review everyone receives the same baseline at the same time, which is faster, but the answers must be consolidated afterwards. Whichever you choose, number the pages first and run Compare PDFs on each returned file against the baseline to see which pages differ.
When to choose which
Sequential review
Choose sequential review when later reviewers need to build on earlier comments, or when the group is small.
Parallel review
Choose parallel review when there is a deadline and the reviewers work on separate matters.
Free tools for both options
Guides that put it into practice
PDF terms explained
- Review roundA review round is one pass in which a document is read, commented on and sent back. Learn how to organize rounds with numbered pages and a comparison between them.
- Change logA change log is a short written list of what changed from one version of a document to the next. Learn what to record and how a page comparison helps you write it.
Common questions
- How many reviewers can I send a file to at once?
- The tools set no limit. The practical limit is how many sets of comments you can reconcile.
- Does AuraDoc merge comments from several reviewers?
- No. It does not merge comment threads. Compare PDFs can show which pages differ from the baseline, and Merge PDF can join files into one.
- How do I avoid confusion between copies?
- Give each copy a clear name with the reviewer and date, number the pages and keep the baseline untouched.